Sunday, 10 September 2017

Review: Son of a Preacher Man, Churchill Bromley

"Saying so much more than
Just words could ever say"

No-one could accuse Craig Revel-Horwood of resting on his laurels. He's about to reprise his Miss Hannigan, stepping into Miranda Hart's sensible shoes, in the West End revival of Annie; the new series of Strictly Come Dancing is looming just around the corner; and inbetween all that, he's found the time to direct and choreograph a new Dusty Springfield jukebox musical that is scheduled to tour the country through to July 2018.

There's a slight sense though that he might have overstretched himself with Son of a Preacher Man as I found its opening engagement at the Churchill Bromley really rather underwhelming. From Warner Brown's insubstantial and weirdly paced book with its eye-openingly poor dialogue, to the incomprehensible decision to expose one of the weaker dancers front and centre at the very start, much of the decision-making feels questionable at best.

I love a good actor-musician production but here, the integration of musicianship and drama just hasn't been thought-through, even down to instruments getting in the way of scenes - it feels a token gesture. Similarly, the incorporation of the many classic Dusty songs is cursorily done, shoehorned into the tales of woe of three random strangers in search of an agony aunt of a record shop (I tell no lies...). There's none of the craft and wit that Mamma Mia (still) epitomises in the jukebox form.

Some of the performances go a long way to papering over the cracks though. Diana Vickers is developing into a beautifully natural stage presence, especially against her love interest here Liam Vincent-Kilbride, and she delivers some cracking vocals as Kat, especially on the rousing finale of the title track, and Ian Reddington is charismatic as Simon, underused but still memorable. 

The trio of the Cappuccino Sisters - Michelle Long, Kate Hardisty and Cassiopeia Berkely-Agyepong - are another highlight with their every appearance but are symptomatic of the show at large, in that they're not really essential to the show, a good idea not particularly well-translated by the creatives.  As the tour progresses, perchance some of these issues will be addressed but I felt there was something more fundamentally flawed here which will require much greater structural changes. As it stands, I think Billy Ray would disown this one. 

Running time: 2 hours 20 minutes (with interval)
Booking until 9th September,then touring to...
New Alexandra Theatre, Birmingham 12 September – 16 September 2017
Sunderland Empire Theatre, Sunderland 19 – 23 September 2017
Palace Theatre, Manchester 26 September – 30 September 2017
Grand Opera House, York 3 October – 7 October 2017
Regent Theatre, Stoke 10 October – 14 October 2017
Festival Theatre, Edinburgh 17 – 21 October 2017
New Theatre, Oxford 24 October – 28 October 2017
Assembly Hall Theatre, Tunbridge Wells 31 October – 4 November 2017
Hull New Theatre, Hull 7 November – 11 November 2017
New Wimbledon Theatre, Wimbledon 14 November – 18 November 2017
Belfast Grand Opera House, Belfast 21 November – 25 November 2017
Wycombe Swan, High Wycombe 28 November – 2 December 2017
Cliffs Pavilion, Southend 16-20 January 2018
Theatre Royal, Nottingham 29 January - 3 February 2018
Belgrade Theatre, Coventry 13-17 February 2018
Waterside Theatre, Aylesbury 6-10 March 2018
Grand Theatre, Blackpool 20-24 March 2018
Princess Theatre, Torquay 10-14 April 2018
Theatre Royal, Brighton 17-21 April 2018
New Victoria Theatre, Woking 24-28 April 2018
King’s Theatre, Glasgow 8-12 May 2018
His Majesty's Theatre, Aberdeen 19-22 June 2018
Liverpool Empire 3-7 July 2018

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is an accurate and fair review above. Some of the individual performances were very good indeed - especially the (dramatically irrelevant) Cappuccino Sisters - and the musicianship was at times very engaging as well. However, there is only so much you can do with what was without doubt the worst script, most tenuous storyline and utterly random stage direction that I have ever experienced. To say the choreography was disappointing would be an understatement too.
So well done to the cast ... and if you are thinking of going to see this show, well ... "willing suspension of disbelief" will be an absolute pre-requisite, even if you love Dusty's originals. Sadly her musical legacy deserves far better than to be associated with this "musical" in its current form, and it is sadly "highly entertaining" for too many of the wrong reasons.

Anonymous said...

Last night at the Alexandra Theatre Birmingham. A bit dissapointing on the whole. Although the cast did a good job, I felt it took too long for it to get going,the intro music was very dreary. Mrs Mop I didn't quite get, what was that all about. The story I thought was weak and singers didn't do some of the wonderful songs justice made famous by Dusty. I expected more glamour, synonymous with Dusty and more dancing, not just prancing and walking about. A bit more glitz and glamour and less choral singing and more sock it to you renditions would lift this show to a different level.